Notchet.com :: Funny Videos,Free Online Games,Funny Pictures,Hot Girls,Bands

Question and Answers with Hassanain Rajabali - 1

Uploaded by: lostprophet786
Video Description:
Following questions were asked:
Why are the units of prayer fixed? Is their any significance?
The outcome of the debate of Hassanain Rajabali called 'Does God not exist'? Debate can be watched on YouTube: http://youtube.com/watch?v=2j0a4Tkjwps
Where you (Hassanain Rajabali) born a Follower of the Family of the Prophet?
Opinion of Darwin Theory of Evolution

Tags for this video: ali allah dua god hajj holy imam islam jihad karbala mosque muslim naik nasheed prophet qari quran ramadhan sheikh shia

Find more videos in the "People" category
See more videos uploaded by lostprophet786

Related Videos

Bridging the Gap of Shia/Sunni for Unity through Discussion	Hassanain Rajabali - Why 40 Days After Karbalaa?	Family Relations- Parents

Islam Denounces Terrorism - Hassanain Rajabali	Hassanain Rajabali - Refuting the Original Sin & Crucifixion	(Justice of Allah ) from Hasanain Rajabali lecture.

Share This Video:

Comments for this video: Show || Hide

Comments for this video on YouTube

Also, Ali (r) was ... ( 6 months ago by alfatourist)

Also, Ali (r) was without a doubt very close to the prophet (s.a.a.s), so were others who helped in his 23 years struggle.
Again, Allah's command in the Quran should alone decide superiority of one over the other.
The fact is, the superiority of one over the other, that is in the eyes of Allah, and not our opinion, is what really counts.
Superiority among followers in the 23 years in the eyes of Allah is based on their degree of taqwa & Allah's mercy.
It is Allah's prerogative and for us to ..

Allah has very ... ( 6 months ago by alfatourist)

Allah has very clearly defined in the first few verses of Baqra, as to who is successful in the eyes of.
They were all successful people, because Allah clearly honored them in the last verse of Baqra (Amanarrasolo..), honored Ayesaha, r.a as Ummolmomineen, clearly honored Abu Bakr in Tauba.
Allah also clearly in Quran promised jannah to the 10.
Also, if someone does not agree, it means Allah did not really know about how those, who Allah is praising, will be conducting themselves in the future.

Also, everything ... ( 6 months ago by alfatourist)

Also, everything fundamental to make or break a Muslim as a Muslim, explicitly emanates from the ultimate guidance, at least at the highest level (without details).
Also, it is not justified to be selective according to preference, in using the rule of not accepting an essential belief, unless it is explicitly given Quran.

Also, if a person ... ( 6 months ago by alfatourist)

Also, if a person selectively uses a principle on fundamental, does not mean he or she is wrong on everything he says about Islam.
The principle is, if a fundamental or essential of deen which can make you or break a you as Muslim or Non Muslim,is not explictly commanded at least the highest level, then it is not not an essential requirment to be a Muslim.

This principle is ... ( 6 months ago by alfatourist)

This principle is valid because all other eseentials are explicitly commanded in Quran at least at the high level (without details).
Valid principle is due to the fact Quran is the only utlimate guidance by itself.
Therefore, You dwell into explanations, historical references for fundamental of deen to prove soemthing, only if the essential is explicitly commmanded by Allah in Quran.

In fact he is much ... ( 6 months ago by alfatourist)

In fact he is much more logical than many shia scholars I have heard.
No hard feelings.
It is obvious what I say.
He is brillian.
But being brilliant does not mean, you can apply a certain princple selectively.
Because I have heard him using the same princple to make his point on other issues.

Explicit command ... ( 6 months ago by alfatourist)

Explicit command means you dont' need to derive or provide explanations to get the basic meaning at the core level.
When it comes to the level where you need to provide with explanations, or inferences to get the basic meanign at the highest level (without detail), then the human input or feedback is involved.
When human feed back is involved it drops to the next level.
It is no longer pure divine.
As an example Zakat is mandated explicitly in Quran, may be at the high level.

It is accepted as ... ( 6 months ago by alfatourist)

It is accepted as essential of deen by all.
Not believing or refusing it will break you as a Non Muslim.
Now if it was not divinely commanded and brought in by scholars through explanations, references, then the process is happening at a different level.
No longer remains an essential tenet of deen.
Important thing is if the divine principle is not used in one case, then it should also not be used selectively to prove another point.

We accept all other ... ( 6 months ago by alfatourist)

We accept all other essential elements of deen, pillars of Islam, based on the same principle, that it must explicitly be commanded in Quran.
Now to accept other essential pillars and claiming them to be from divine and, not using this principle, is not fair.
It is called double standard.
It is called being selective to prove your point.

That is why pure ... ( 6 months ago by alfatourist)

That is why pure revelation is a different set and category and exist at the pure divine level.
That is why Quran walk is a different set of activivity at a different level, which involved divine inspiration and logical use of brain.
Let us not accept anything as basic tenet of deen, or pillars of Islam, that is not explicitly commanded by Allah through revelation.

Let us use ... ( 6 months ago by alfatourist)

Let us use traditions, explanations, only to elaborate on the essential commanded in Quran.
The order or sequence must be set right to get the facts staright.

Also, it is not ... ( 6 months ago by alfatourist)

Also, it is not appropriate & consistent with Quran to call or consider ourselves other than MUSLIM.
The Muslim like the model of prophet.
Did the prohet set the model of Muslim or not?

There are others ... ( 6 months ago by alfatourist)

There are others too, who have come up with essential of deen on the same basis, it does not have to be explicitly commanded in Quran, the meaning could be produced,derived or inferred with explanation & other references & logic.
This practice of asserting essentials of deen, even if it is not explictly commanded in Quran, is the root cause of sectarian divide.

The practice of not ... ( 6 months ago by alfatourist)

The practice of not using the right order or sequence is the root cause of sectarian divide.
Something that is pillar of Islam in the eyes of any group, not explicity commanded in quran at least at the hig level (no detail), does not have to be even considered for explanations, interpretation or deriving inferences.

It is like if the ... ( 6 months ago by alfatourist)

It is like if the sponsor has not officially or explicitly stated that he or she will investing 1 billion dollar on the project and, someone says, I have proof from multiple sources that the manager allowed the 1 billion dollars, if someone denies it, he is a liar.
Where are the funds going to come from, if the sponsor has not explicitly given the confirmation regarding the investment.
It has to go in the proper sequence. Otherwise, the logic is flawed.

In fact this is the ... ( 6 months ago by alfatourist)

In fact this is the rule being used for other critical issues in Islam like Zakat, salaat, Haj, saum, and selectively not being used for Imamat.
No hard feelings.
It is simple clear logic without bias and love for all for the sake of Allah.

Has this guy ever ... ( 3 months ago by FartheadOgre)

Has this guy ever debated an atheist?

he debated with Dan ... ( 3 months ago by weststainesmassiv79)

he debated with Dan Barker and Richard Carrier. watch?v=oocFLfoT0Q4

Array ( 2 months ago by alfatourist)

Bottom Line
If you see any being other than Allah and his rasool, from outside the bounds of those 23 years becoming fundamental to your belief set, it should raise a red flag, that your belief set is corrupted.

" The learned ... ( 2 months ago by lilshnappinturtle)

" The learned scholar with his back to a pillar and his students around him, sometimes moved to tears of appreciation by the elegance of his exposition. "
May God's Blessings be on all of you.

:'( the quality is ... ( 1 month ago by MARYYAY)

:'( the quality is pretty pooo
but thank you anyway haha :D

Eloquence does not ... ( 1 month ago by santacharlie)

Eloquence does not mean the person is speaking accurately or is logical on every issue.
Sometime one does not need to got into details, they become irrelevant, though eloquently presented, because the unavoidable exclusive requirement of 23 years, rules out the importance of details beyond 23 years being conveyed eloquently.
He may not be inaccurate on everything.
In fact he may be very informative & excellent on few things.

But once you ... ( 1 month ago by santacharlie)

But once you deviate from the essential 23 years belief set requirement for success, you are not meeting the minimum requirement that was met by those who passed away as Muslims in those 23 years, in the presence of the prophet as the last messenger.
As a Muslim if we learn from the prophet's family or other pious Muslims who lived in those 23 years, we actually learn about the prophet's way and, that is the real intention.

These good people ... ( 2 weeks ago by minimadmonkey)

These good people were with the Prophet for 23 years, and from them, we learn the Prophet prayed in four different manners.
wa salaam