and you personally ...( 3 weeks ago by extinguishersoul)
and you personally knew John Lennon enough to say something like that? otherwise shut the fuck up...
Uhh tough-guy! Of ...( 3 weeks ago by comeonfuckingcunt)
Uhh tough-guy! Of course John would have hated it. Are you deaf???
john wasnt a ...( 3 weeks ago by extinguishersoul)
john wasnt a hateful kind of guy... and you have no idea what he would like..
I love John, but he ...( 3 weeks ago by comeonfuckingcunt)
I love John, but he could be very hateful. have you not heard "How do you sleep"? And he would not have liked this terrible version of his masterpiece. He hated all the versions The Beatles did of the song and this one is NOT better.
Andy Fairweather ...( 3 weeks ago by SOADium20)
Andy Fairweather looks funny.
THIS SUCKS( 2 weeks ago by SephynnXx)
THIS SUCKS
and thats your ...( 2 weeks ago by extinguishersoul)
and thats your opinion! john's may have been different sir
Roger why are you ...( 2 weeks ago by andreassalomee)
Roger why are you treating us in this way?
roger deserves a ...( 2 weeks ago by gwyllum18)
roger deserves a kick in the sack for this-what crap
JHon was a freedom ...( 2 weeks ago by deansusky)
JHon was a freedom fighter given so many interviews at univercities his death was set up watch documentry on history channel lennon was the greatest roger did a poor job at this song
Jeez, people, get ...( 2 weeks ago by SallieSimpson)
Jeez, people, get over it. It's just a cover! Yeah, it's not all that great, but it's not some horrible abomination against John Lennon...get a grip.
I'm not upset ...( 1 week ago by gwyllum18)
I'm not upset because its "a horrible abomination against John Lennon" but because its a really shitty piece of music by a guy who we all know can do much better. Two sackings for Roger and maybe a smack in the gob as well.
Like all of Waters ...( 1 week ago by kstandidge)
Like all of Waters music since 1984, utter crap.I don't think he would have made it on his own had he not been involved with Floyd.
lol i completely ...( 1 week ago by londonladdy)
lol i completely agree
Eh...I honestly ...( 1 week ago by SallieSimpson)
Eh...I honestly don't see what's so bad about it. I don't think Roger intended it to be a masterpiece. Definitely not something worth getting violent urges about. lol
Probably not, but ...( 1 week ago by SallieSimpson)
Probably not, but you could say that about any member of the band.
Some of Gilmour's ...( 1 week ago by kstandidge)
Some of Gilmour's stuff is OK, and Floyd managed well without Waters. My description of Waters is Great lyricist, but lousy vocalist. That said it was great to see them perform together at Live 8.
Kicking a celeb in ...( 1 week ago by gwyllum18)
Kicking a celeb in the bag for being a prat isn't satisfying a violent urge, its merely justice served. But now we're back to sacrilege. If he didn't intend for his cover of a great song to be a masterpiece in some way then maybe he should have not bothered at all or covered some silly pop song that noone takes seriously. People who do crappy, half-assed versions of anyone else's fine work deserve-you guessed it-a kick in the bag.
sings it better ...( 1 week ago by yogaman1919)
sings it better than any of us here. so pipe down.
No matter how he ...( 1 week ago by SallieSimpson)
No matter how he did it, there's going to be someone out there whining about it and saying it's terrible, an insult to John Lennon, blah blah blah. I just think people get too worked up about covers in general, and some people here are taking it way too seriously. JMO...
I don't think he is ...( 1 week ago by SallieSimpson)
I don't think he is a lousy vocalist given the right material. I mean, can you imagine Gilmour or anyone else singing the songs he sings on The Wall for example? His voice is perfect for that kind of style. And I don't think any of the stuff they did seperately was as good as their work together. Gilmour is fairly boring without Waters, IMO, and Waters' solo stuff suffered musically without the rest of the band's input.
is this during the ...( 1 week ago by Halaberdizzle)
is this during the Radio Kaos era?
Funny to see Roger ...( 6 days ago by Nebnyr)
Funny to see Roger grooving to pop in memory of John Lennon. Roger around this time had formally given up trying to be popular except for the one-off Radio Kaos which had some poor excuses for label-pleasing pop on it, but was all-in-all just a bad album. He found a happy medium with Amused to Death, though Pros and Cons is his best solo album and it is even more anti-pop than Final Cut, which is a Floyd classic, btw.
and you have no idea what he would like..
And I don't think any of the stuff they did seperately was as good as their work together. Gilmour is fairly boring without Waters, IMO, and Waters' solo stuff suffered musically without the rest of the band's input.