The reductionistic ...( 11 months ago by smithsherman)
The reductionistic approach to time in this performance undermines the lovely tone production and sound.Notes endlessly falling on the downbeat unvaried,no contrasting of parts through a varied sync,a dictatorial central tempo enslaving most phrases. This view of Frescobaldi is such a negative one,it's hard to brook.
That's interesting. ...( 11 months ago by Trinitrotolaissance)
That's interesting... Perhaps you could upload or send me a recording of this piece played by someone else? A version which you like more, maybe you can change my mind :-)
It get alot from it ...( 10 months ago by buccaneer84)
It get alot from it, fun, bright, fragrant enchanting, sharp, flourishing...lovely I think Leonhardt brings the heart of frescobaldi out so well. it feels so great to hear his plays of them.
Yes, I felt the ...( 10 months ago by Trinitrotolaissance)
Yes, I felt the same. But I haven't really heard any other interpretations yet nor did I work on this piece yet myself. I think there's one more video of this piece on youtube, played on organ though.
im so glad you ...( 10 months ago by buccaneer84)
im so glad you liked it aswell!, not everyone absorbs these things the same, so its nice to know when others have!. thanks for uploading this Jan! birds of a feather, flock together :]
Go see ...( 9 months ago by smithsherman)
Go see Ernststolz.You have my permission to imagine it better when you hear only failure.
WHO needs your ...( 9 months ago by buccaneer84)
WHO needs your permission! Where were you circa 1600?! ... if you are serious, your view has been like that of an arrogant pompous jerk. We have seen tons of your comments, and it seems like you enjoy using some "deceptively complicated" language to de-grade or detract things you dont enjoy or understand. Quit that junk "smithsherman" :[ you should Acknowledge Their Effort*
Yes smithsherman , ...( 9 months ago by Trinitrotolaissance)
Yes smithsherman , that's a rather strange comment...
On second thought, ...( 9 months ago by buccaneer84)
On second thought, ive realized that you may not have been as serious as i took, and that your comments are your "opinions". I really think you are a great guy "smithsherman" with a incredibly complex knowledge. Though simply this Song and play by G.Leonhardt has sailed fragrant joys through my Soul, so instinctively i was 'defensive'. Please forgive*
FRESCO!!!!!( 9 months ago by Veraeikon)
FRESCO!!!!!
If his view of ...( 8 months ago by smithsherman)
If his view of Frescobaldi were to be correct,then Frescobaldi was a superficial and boring metronomish pedant of the 20th century.
So which performer ...( 8 months ago by Trinitrotolaissance)
So which performer actually gives us a correct view of Frescobaldi, specifically this piece? Superficial and boring metronomish recordings are .midi tracks. And this recording as far from being such a .midi computer generated track. I think Leonhardt does a lot of special things timing wise and with his articulation.
Dear Buc,I was in ...( 7 months ago by smithsherman)
Dear Buc,I was in France in 1600 serving in Henry's army as a pikeman,who spent his free time playing the recorder.
Dear Buc,All is ...( 7 months ago by smithsherman)
Dear Buc,All is well,and although I dislike it...if it renders you felicitous,that's wonderful.
Just ignore Mrs. ...( 2 months ago by Endarkened666)
Just ignore Mrs. Sherman. All this idiot does is waste his time and bash musicians whose interpretation doesn't match his own narrow view of beauty. Seriously, i don't know where he finds the time...oh wait, yes i do...he has no life. His account has been closed. Probably because he received so much hate mail. I feel sorry for this guy, but would still kick his ass if i saw him.
I love that saying ...( 1 week ago by jannokas85)
I love that saying :). So good to know that the baddies will get their's one day :D! Peace!
This view of Frescobaldi is such a negative one,it's hard to brook.
Perhaps you could upload or send me a recording of this piece played by someone else? A version which you like more, maybe you can change my mind :-)
birds of a feather, flock together :]
to de-grade or detract things you dont enjoy or understand. Quit that junk "smithsherman" :[ you should Acknowledge Their Effort*
simply this Song and play by G.Leonhardt has sailed fragrant joys through my Soul, so instinctively i was 'defensive'. Please forgive*
Superficial and boring metronomish recordings are .midi tracks. And this recording as far from being such a .midi computer generated track. I think Leonhardt does a lot of special things timing wise and with his articulation.
All this idiot does is waste his time and bash musicians whose interpretation doesn't match his own narrow view of beauty. Seriously, i don't know where he finds the time...oh wait, yes i do...he has no life. His account has been closed. Probably because he received so much hate mail. I feel sorry for this guy, but would still kick his ass if i saw him.
Peace!